Bakery Pre-Orders

Our bakery items are made fresh daily, year-round, and taste soooo good! We must be doing something right because our delicious pies are so popular we make over 5,000 pies in three days for Thanksgiving plus all the other yummy items we make for you and your family. To ensure you get your favorite bakery items, be sure to place your holiday pre-orders early! To learn more about Pre-order pickup visit our Pre-order Pickup page.

Bakery Items are available at our year-round Smith Market location at 3341 Winchester Pike, Columbus, OH 43232 only. Stop by and shop from our large selection of mouth-watering bakery items. Visit our Locations page for directions.
• Pre-orders are accepted online 24/7.
• We need approximately 24 hours notice to fill a pre-order. Before placing your order, you will be asked to select a pickup date and time.
Payment: You pay for your order at the market when you pick it up.
Pickup Time:What happens if you miss your pickup time? Most of the time, missing your pickup time is not a problem. We will hold your order until close of pickup day with the exception of Thanksgiving orders. Because we sell out so quickly, bakery items ordered for Thanksgiving must be picked up during the time you choose. We are not able to hold your order beyond that time.
• Due to COVID, supply issues may be beyond our control. If there are any changes to your order, we will call you ASAP.
Large Pre-Orders:If you have a large quantity order, (over 10 items), please call the bakery in advance (614) 235-2014
• Change or Cancel Pre-order: If you need to change or cancel your order, please call us at (614) 235-2014
Special Holiday Products Availability:

Valentine’s Day: Starting January 31
Easter: Starting 2 weeks before Easter
Thanksgiving: Starting September 30
Christmas: Starting the day after Thanksgiving