Pre-Order Pickup is now available for our Smith Farm Bakery items.

 Be sure to order ahead for the holidays or any day!

Call the Smith Farm Bakery in Columbus, OH to place your Pre-Orders today @614-235-2014

Our Store is Packed with Bulk & Amish Foods  

Check out the great flavors of The Witten Farm Market with our very own jams, jellies, fruit butters, pickles, and salsa. We also sell local honey, frozen meats, Amish foods, specialty dips, bulk foods and more at our local Columbus market.


A wide selection of honey and bee pollen from the local hives of Elk Creek Honey Farm. Raw, all-natural honey available in  ½ lb, 1 lb and 5 lb bottles along with several different flavors of creamed and infused honey.

Blueberry Blossom
Chocolate Mint
Orange Blossom
Raspberry Blossom

Creamed Honey
Creamed Cinnamon

Cinnamon Infused
Habanero Infused
Lemon Infused


Jams, Jellies & Fruit Butters

Over 20 flavors of jams and jellies, ranging from the traditional strawberry and peach to the more adventurous Red Raspberry Jalapeno.  You’re sure to find a flavor to enjoy. Our customers’ favorites include: 

  • Blackberry (seedless)
  • Black Raspberry (seedless)
  • Blueberry
  • Peach
  • Red Raspberry (seedless)
  • Strawberry

Many of our flavors are also available in sugar free options.

Don’t forget about the Fruit Butters…Thick, smooth and easy to spread, they are the perfect way to liven up your breakfast toast.  

  • Apple Butter
  • Cherry Butter
  • Peach Butter
  • Pumpkin Butter
  • Sweet Potato Butter


Keep it sweet with peach salsa or go wild with Ghost Chili.  Mild, Medium and Hot, our salsa selection will please every taste bud.  And you’ve gotta try our Queso Blanco. With the perfect blend of cheese and spices, you’ll feel like your eating at your favorite Mexican restaurant.

  • Black Bean & Corn Salsa
  • Chimichanga Salsa
  • Ghost Chili
  • Peach
  • Pepperpatch Salsa
  • Salsa Grande
  • Six Shooter Fire Roasted Salsa
  • Tomatillo Avocado Salsa
  • Queso Blanco

Pickles & Pickled Veggies

Crisp, Crunchy and packed with flavor, they make the perfect snack or side dish.

Bread & Butter Pickles
Farmhouse Pickles
Habanero Chunk Pickles
What’cha Dill Pickles

Pickled Vegetables
Beet Balls
Pickled Asparagus
Pickled Brussel Sprouts
Pickled Okra

Local Frozen Meats

Cuts of beef, chicken, pork and bison from 3-D Meats in Dalton, OH

Ground Beef
Ground Beef Patties
Chuck Roasts


Chicken Breast
Chicken Tenders


Hot Dogs
Pork Chops
Salt & Pepper Sausage Links
Smoked Sausage
Sweet/Hot Italian Pork Sausage


Gourmet Turkey from Bowman & Landes in New Carlisle, OH

Italian Turkey Breast
Mesquite Turkey Breast
Turkey Bratwurst

Dip Mixes & Baking Mixes

Quick and Simple with a a gourmet taste.  Everyone will think you’ve spent hours in the kitchen…but don’t worry, we won’t tell.

Dip Mixes
Artichoke & Spinach
Caramelized Onion
Dill Pickle
Garden Medley
Horseradish & Bacon
White Cheddar Jalapeno
And More…

Baking Mixes
Apple Crisp
Apple Fritter
Apple Spice Cake
Blueberry Muffin
Peach Crisp
Peach Cobbler
Shortcake Cobbler
Buttermilk Pancake (We have Maple Syrup too!)


Sweet and  Salty, our snack collection can satisfy any craving.

Beef Jerky
Caramel Corn
Cheese Crisps
Chocolate Covered Cherries, Blueberries
Espresso Beans
Chocolate Dipped Peanuts
Kettle Corn

Corn Nuts
Popcorn Balls
Old Fashioned Candies
Peanut Brittle
Sunfower Seeds
Trail Mix

In the Fridge...

Variety of Amish Cheeses
Cheese Curds
Chicken Salad
Amish Roll butter
Trail bologna
Cottage Ham
Old Fashioned Root Beers & Cream Sodas


3341 Winchester Pike
Columbus, OH 43232

Call or Email Us

Spring Hours

Garden Center & Bakery

Open Daily 8am-7pm

Produce Market Opening Late April